Go to home page - diocesan shield

The Anglican Church in Tasmania                                                             Search

a healthy church...transformingLIFE

Tasmanian anglican

June 2005

 

Review - Memory and Identity

This book originated from discussions between the late Pope and leading intellectuals at his Summer Residence of Castel Gadolfo.
Reviewed by Philip Blake

The idea of conversations is continued in the book as each section is prefaced by editorial questions. This is sometimes more helpful than others. It is no light reading matter, and although it is not essential, such reading can be assisted by a little knowledge of Latin.

Pope John Paul II tackled some basic theological, historical and philosophical questions concerning good and evil, freedom, patriotism, the European situation and democracy. He was a very Polish Pontiff and at times Poland seems to get inordinate coverage.

There are some sections like the one on 'Justification by Faith' where readers of the Reformed faith will respond with a loud Amen. There are others which will be appreciated by some schools of thought, and not others!

The work contains considerable reference to Scripture and to Papal Encyclicals and the book reveals a man who was well-versed in theological, social and philosophical disciplines. Chapter 10, 'The Mystery of Mercy' is really a commentary on the Miserere (Psalm 51) and the result is a contribution of great feeling and understanding. However it is somewhat weakened by the omission of any reference to the harm done to people and the Church by sexual exploitation and the need for repentance and forgiveness.

The reader will also be aware that certain issues facing the Roman Catholic Church today, such as the married priesthood, contraception and the place of women in the apostolate are conspicuous by their absence. However, there is much to be gained from reading and discussing this book of personal reflections.

The final chapter of the book takes the form of a discussion about the attempt to assassinate the Pope on 13th May 1981. It is a study in prayer and providence and a picture of the continuing struggle between good and evil.

The late Pope's comments near the close of this book are significant. There is no evil from which God cannot draw a greater good. There is no suffering which he cannot transform into a path leading to him.


Retired priest the Rev. Dr Philip Blake reads widely and is a member of the Parish of Holy Trinity, Launceston.

 

 

  


Memory and Identity, by Pope John Paul II. Weidenfeld and Nicholson, London 2005, 198pp. RRP $35