Go to home page - diocesan shield

The Anglican Church in Tasmania                                                             Search

a healthy church...transformingLIFE

Tasmanian Anglican

July 2004

 

 

 

 

 


History in Quotations by M.J. Cohen and John Major. Cassell, London 2004 Hardcover, 1008 pp, RRP $75

 

Book review
History in Quotations

reviewed by Philip Blake

 

 

Historical books are frequently written as a commentary (as the author conceived it) on distant or more recent events. Quotations are often used in an attempt to vindicate the opinions of the writer.

Too many quotes can break the flow of the writing or even detract from the declared aim. While the opinions of historians are important, the words from the original sources are of even greater value!

Addictive

What we have here is a book of quotations covering more than 5000 years of recorded world history. The authors of this publication are well qualified in historical research, international understanding, writing and publishing. The result is a massive work of some 9000 quotations arranged in 90 thematic chapters. The book is heavy to hold but illuminating in its content. The ability to find the original words of an historical figure rather than someone else's commentary can be pleasing, rewarding and addictive!

Fast food

In his foreword to the book, Simon Schama who has become well-known for his visual history of Great Britain, said: ‘Sometimes we don't want the whole banquet, soup to nuts. Sometimes, often even, we crave dim sum, tapas, a day filled, stuffed with hors d'oeuvres. And it is then that one needs a good book of quotations to nibble on...’

Quotations are really no fast-food delicacies. They require interpretation by the reader and an ability to consider the circumstances surrounding the quotation. Thomas Paine who wrote: ‘I rarely ever quote, the reason is, I always think!’ missed the point. By their very nature quotations are not always ‘user-friendly’. However, they allow us to enter into the person of the writer in a way that no other form will allow us to do.

Timely

I am aware of no other book which in a single volume covers such a significant and broad period of world history, and provides so many insights into the persons and words of so many people. The book is supported by a comprehensive index of speakers and subjects. Each quotation is complemented by a biographical footnote. This is a timely and important publication which meets a real need. It is worthy of a place on your bookshelf, even if it means discarding other books to make room for it.

Happy nibbling, lunching and feasting!